It's actually FAR better than I remembered it.
"These are REAL men. The only way to get them out of those buildings is feet first..."
[German corporal and Stalingrad veteran reporting back to his Officer Commanding]
There are several points to make about this docudrama film. Firstly, it's a documentary drama. Most action films take liberties with real events for dramatic effect. This film doesn't. It's purpose is to honour the men of the 1st Airborne Division who fought - and died - there. It doesn't need to exaggerate, given the legendary stand at Arnhem. The people involved would have considered it bad form and insulting to their dead comrades.
Where the epic "A Bridge Too Far" covers Operation Market-Garden as a whole, this film covers only the two battles of the British 1st Airborne Division at Arnhem bridge and in Oosterbeek. The timeline is more correct and easier to follow.
Fans of "A Bridge Too Far" will see scenes that shall be very familiar. The scene of the Airborne soldier running out to recover a CLE supplies container is more realistic in this film: these things were incredibly heavy. Sadly, both films miss many of the events during the battle. Only a miniseries might manage that.
I last saw this film when I was a teenager before I knew any Arnhem veterans. I (wrongly) remembered it for having Mr Cholmondley-Warner-esque acting but rewatching it, it's nowhere near so bad. It's actually really good! I actually prefer it to "A Bridge Too Far".
Some of the actors may seem wooden at times: the "actors" are in fact many of the people who took part in the battle. They're not Oscar nominees but they bring the authenticity of experienced and skilled war veterans who'd been there and done it. Most notable are Majors Gough and Lonsdale, who each played a significant part of the battle; war correspondents Stanley Maxted and Alan Wood who reported the battle around them, and; Dutch civilians Father Dyker and Kate ter Horst who tended to the wounded. The mind boggles at what went through the minds of the veterans of the battle as they revisited the still wrecked town a year after and re-enacted their experiences.
It's good to see the real people involved - particularly the Dutch to whom so much is owed - if only to privately honour them.
The film is interwoven with footage shot during the battle. The war cameramen were Sergeants Mike Lewis, Dennis Smith and Gordon Walker. Although all men were parachutists, it was Sgt Lewis who jumped, filming during his descent - as a former Paratrooper AND studio photographer who's done this with a more modern and smaller 35mm stills camera, I can tell you that this is no mean feat!
They jumped from 450-500 feet as opposed to the 650+ feet of peacetime. Because Sgt Lewis used a wide angle lens, it looks MUCH higher. He got a great deal of high quality footage for the mere seconds that he was in the air. His footage is another scene recreated in "A Bridge Too Far" - but impossible to surpass.
One of the realistic details in this film is that you don't see the enemy soldiers in close detail, except at the field hospital - much like in real war. Flame throwers widely used, too, along with tanks the biggest problems for the Airborne soldiers at Arnhem. In this battle, German and British soldiers were often occupying the same buildings, attacking and counterattacking for occupancy of each room.
For fans of "A Bridge Too Far", it's DEFINITELY well worth watching if only to see the scenes that inspired the scenes in the 1977 film.
INCIDENTALLY:
In his broadcast, Stanley Maxted introduces himself as "Maxted, Stanley Maxted". Considering that this film was partially scripted by the man who later became director of the earlier James Bond films, I can't help feeling that Maxted's 1944 battlefield broadcast inspired a staple idiosyncracy of the James Bond franchise.
The composer of the film "A Bridge Too Far", John Addison, was a member of 30 Corps during Operation Market-Garden. In my opinion, his music for "A Bridge Too Far" is genuine brilliance. That said, you might notice occasional "bits" from this film that seem to be echoed in "A Bridge Too Far". I've long felt that some of the more tragic parts of the "A Bridge Too Far" music are reminiscent of Tchaikovsky's "Swan Lake", especially 35 seconds and again at 1:31 minutes into the "Swan Theme".
THE DVD:
The only options/features of the DVD are "Play Feature" and "Scene Selection". So long after the battle, isn't it a pity that there's no-one available to make a director's commentary feature?!
Sadly, the colour depiction of a Paratrooper on the DVD cover has MANY faults - but I'm REALLY nit-picking. Modern parachutes behind, postwar Smock, totally wrong badge in place of where a modern DZ flash would be, wrong rifle, futuristic grenade...
Verified purchase: YesCondition: Pre-owned